August 2022 Landlord/Tenant Questions & Answers

1. Question: My tenant has some damage to the outside window to the house I rent to them.  The tenant claims the damage was done by a burglary attempt but I suspect they locked themselves out and damaged the window when trying to get back in.  Who is responsible for the repair?

Answer: Unless proved otherwise, damage to the premises caused by unknown third parties, acts of nature, or unexplainable are the responsibility of the landlord.

2. Question: In a co-signer situation what forms do you recommend that the co-signer sign along with the tenant?

Answer: They should sign a separate guarantee agreement that has been reviewed by competent counsel. 

3. Question: As resident managers, we are dealing with several tenants in violation of pet rules.  In retaliation, they have made false accusations of us entering their apartments without notice.  They are now disturbing other tenants with this untruth and questioning our integrity.  How can we protect or defend ourselves?

Answer: You can serve a three-day-notice to perform conditions and/or covenants or quit to permanently remove the unauthorized pets unless prevented by local COVID moratorium.  If you can prove the pets are still there after the notice expires, you can file for unlawful detainer.

4. Question: In assessing a late charge in a lease, is there a law stating how many days after the due date must expire before a late charge can be imposed?

Answer: California law does not prohibit a landlord from charging the tenant a bona fide late charge after the rent is delinquent.  The rent is not delinquent unless one business day has passed at the time the rent became due.  If the rent is due on the first and the first is on a weekend, a late charge could not be imposed until after the first business day expires. Pay attention to local COVID moratoria which may prevent a late fee from being charged. Also note that SB 91 prohibits late fees on COVID rental debt.

5. Question: What happens when the lease expires?  Is it assumed that the agreement goes month-to-month?  Or should a new agreement be signed?

Answer: If the lease does not speak to renewal or reversion to month-to-month and the tenant remains in the premises with the landlord’s consent, the law will presume a month-to-month agreement if the rent is paid and accepted by the landlord.  It then can be terminated by either side serving the other with an appropriate notice to quit unless state or local rent control prevents you from serving the notice.

6. Question: I have a lease with two male tenants.  The lease specifies two occupants only.  One of the tenants has a girlfriend who spends the night every day of the week for the last month.  How do you determine when a guest is an occupant?

Answer: Unless the tenant admits to having another person move into the rental unit, you need to prove that they are occupying the unit through circumstantial evidence.  Proof of facts such as receiving mail at the premises, coming to and from work on a daily basis, using the amenities without the named tenants, present on weekends, or making requests from management all could lead a trier of fact to conclude that the person is an occupant of the premises. Your lease may also provide direction on how often people may be on the property and for how long.

7. Question: Is there a law for returning the security deposit within a certain time frame?  If I missed the due date is there an automatic penalty?  I overlooked accounting for a deposit, and it has been 25 days.

Answer: California law allows residential tenants and landlords to contract for up to 21 days for the accounting and, if applicable, return of all or a portion of the tenant’s security deposit.  There is no automatic penalty for being late but you may no longer be able to deduct from the deposit.

8. Question: When we have called attention to a violation of the lease or community rules, tenants frequently will say we are “picking” on them.  How can we protect ourselves?

Answer: First, make sure you are enforcing the lease and community rules equally to all violators.  The best way to avoid or minimize legal challenges is by documenting all incidents and responding in a consistent manner.

9. Question: When typing up a new lease, should we use the spelling of the tenant’s names as it appears on the application or on their driver’s license?

Answer: It is important to be consistent on how you spell their name in the event legal action is necessary.  It is best to use the name exactly as it appears on their driver’s license and request that they fill out the application in a manner consistent with this request.

10. Question: If a one-year residential lease is broken, what becomes of the security deposit?

Answer: Once the tenants have vacated the premises and the landlord has taken over possession, the time to account for the use of the security deposit (normally 21 days) begins.  The deposit can be used for any monies owed the landlord including delinquent rent.

11. Question: I have single family homes that I have for lease.  They have large, well- maintained gardens.  How do I best insure that they are kept up?

Answer: Your best bet is to hire a gardener yourself, build the cost into the rent and have the lease read that the gardener has permission to enter the property for gardening/landscaping/mowing etc.  That way you have more control.

Kimball, Tirey & St. John LLP is a full service real estate law firm representing residential and commercial property owners and managers. This article is for general information purposes only. While KTS provides clients with information on legislative changes, our courtesy notifications are not meant to be exhaustive and do not take the place of legislative services or membership in trade associations. Our legal alerts are provided on selected topics and should not be relied upon as a complete report of all new changes of local, state, and federal laws affecting property owners and managers. Laws may have changed since this article was published.  Before acting, be sure to receive legal advice from our office. For contact information, please visit our website:  For past Legal Alerts, Questions & Answers and Legal Articles, please consult the resource section of our website.

© 2022 Kimball, Tirey and St. John LLP